29 Comments

I’m definitely hearing bass drum as well

Expand full comment

All the way through I Want To Be Happy. Just listened with headphones - Roy is playing it

Expand full comment

Can you cite a specific timing? Thanks Andrew

Expand full comment

During the out chorus there are spots where he uses bass drum prominently. There’s also a fill where I hear at least one Tom-tom (maybe two). During the ending I hear a crash cymbal, and at the very end I hear him playing hi hat and playing what sounds like a crash and hitting a ride cymbal. All of that adds up to a full drum kit. 🤷🏻‍♂️

Expand full comment

Thanks to both of you, I have added info about Roy Haynes's set and removed the comment about the incomplete set. Look again please. THANK YOU ANDREW and GLENN!

Expand full comment

Very nice recording, and fine restoration job by Mr. Accardi.

A note about the technology and the need to synchronized the sound from the left and right heads. Modern stereo tape heads were built as a pair within the same block, but before stereo recording became common, machines were built with two heads, staggered from each other along the tape path. Unless you have the machine in which the tape was recorded, or have detailed knowledge of the head spacing, it takes a combination of great musical ears and use of electronic instrumentation, in addition to the editing software capable of moving one track with respect to the other.

Bert Whyte used such a machine specially built by his employer to record the Kenton band at the Blue Note in September 1952 with a spaced pair of world class Neumann microphones.. Because he was running at a fast tape speed to maximize quality, the edited recording was only 27 minutes, but the sound quality is spectacular, and the band is full of future stars.

Wally Heider, just starting to learn live recording, very prolifically recorded almost anything worthwhile he could find in the '50s, beginning in 1952. I've collected more than 100 CDs, nearly all of them bootlegs, culminating in his recordings of the Terry Gibbs Dream Band. The first of his stereo recordings that I've found were done in November 1956 of the Kenton band in one of the later nights of a long run in San Francisco. It's particularly interesting because Pepper Adams was on the band and playing so great that some of the band's soloists were giving him their solos.

Expand full comment

Thanks for clarifying this trchnical issue I was wondering about since my 1964 tape recorder has two channel stereo heads in no need of synchronization.

Expand full comment

Yes, I did not explain the technical details, but I can tell you that on all these tapes, when played back on a more modern tape deck, you can hear a definite delay between the left and right channels. It sounds like an echo and I could not have posted it without the corrections of Accardi. Thank you Jim and Bo!

Expand full comment

amazing!!!! Bud Alive!!!!!!!!

Thank you so much, Lewis.

Expand full comment

Man— even with minimal kit, Roy still sounds good. Fascinating to hear him work with the stripped down kit. I only had time for a minute— will check out more later.

Expand full comment

I assume you’ve heard the magical live gig of Bud with Roy and Mingus. For me, this new dose of Bud and Roy is now a nice companion piece to that amazing recording.

Expand full comment

Yes, that's great stuff from 1953. And of course Bud and Roy recorded in the studio for Blue Note, and were recorded together on other occasions. THANK YOU KARL

Expand full comment

I realize now that he does have a full kit, but for some reason was choosing to play mostly high hat.

Expand full comment

Great job, Lewis. Eugene Holley, Jr. here, and I’m on Substack as Sound and the Mainstream!

Expand full comment

Very exciting! Good to know. THANK YOU EUGENE

Expand full comment

I've always wondered why most 1950's California pianists picked up on Bud Powell while their saxophone partners laid back a generation on Lester Young.

Piano: Lou Levy, Russ Freeman, Carl Perkins, Hampton Hawes, Richard Twardzik, Andre Previn, Pete Jolly.

Sax: Bob Cooper, Paul Desmond, Wardell Gray, Bud Shank, Art Pepper, Bill Perkins, Richie Kamuca, Jack Montrose, Lennie Niehaus.

Expand full comment

Yes, it's a good example of how far off critics can be. All those pianists got labeled under "cool" but when someone really listens, as you have, one hears a particularly intense and percussive approach. THANK YOU CRAIG

Expand full comment

Hi Lewis,

Great piece and always great to hear more Bud. I was interested in your comment about Bud’s left hand, and wondered if now, or in a subsequent post, you could elaborate more about his earlier “low rumbles”.

Thanks as always

David P

Expand full comment

At some point I want to do a post about Bud's recordings of 1949/50. THANK YOU DAVID!

Expand full comment

Oh my! What a treasure, treat and inspiration! Thank you for sharing these jewels from the modern master!

Expand full comment

Thank you! I've posted over 200 essays to date--check out the Index on the home page or just browse through. THANK YOU SUMI !

Expand full comment

If Powell had not been perennially dealing with bad physical and mental health, he could have had a much longer career. As it is, his piano legacy remains impressive.

Expand full comment

Yes, unfortunately on some of his recordings he is clearly in poor shape. But we are lucky to have so many brilliant moments captured on recordings!

Expand full comment

I have seen Lester Young’s nickname spelled Prez and Pres. I know he was The President, but which spelling is correct? Or are both good?

Expand full comment

Both are good, although I think "Pres" was used more on recordings released during his lifetime. THANK YOU ANIBAL

Expand full comment

Amazing! Thank you for sharing, Mr Porter.

Expand full comment

THANK YOU!

Expand full comment

Thank you for sharing these recordings and their context. It is always a treat to hear some Bud Powell I haven’t heard before. Happy holidays!

Expand full comment

THANK YOU and the same to you!

Expand full comment